Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-c47g7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-20T10:36:58.661Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

GUILT, ANGER, AND RETRIBUTION

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 June 2010

Raffaele Rodogno
Raffaele Rodogno*
Affiliation:
Aarhus University, Denmarkfilrr@hum.au.dk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article focuses primarily on the emotion of guilt as providing a justification for retributive legal punishment. In particular, I challenge the claim according to which guilt can function as part of our epistemic justification of positive retributivism, that is, the view that wrongdoing is both necessary and sufficient to justify punishment. I show that the argument to this conclusion rests on two premises: (1) to feel guilty typically involves the judgment that one deserves punishment; and (2) those who feel guilty after wrongdoing are more virtuous (or less vicious) than those who do not. I shall argue that premise (1) is false on both empirical and conceptual grounds and that there are no particularly good grounds supporting this premise (2). Finally, I consider and reject the claim that anger, as opposed to guilt, can afford the type of epistemic justification needed by positive retributivism.

Type
Research Article
Information
Legal Theory , Volume 16 , Issue 1 , March 2010 , pp. 59 - 76
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2010

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

REFERENCES

Aristotle. (1984) Complete Works. Revised Oxford Translation, vol. 2., ed. Barnes, J.. (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press).Google Scholar
Baumeister, Roy F., Stilwell, Arlene M., and Heatherton, Todd F.. (1994) “Guilt: An Interpersonal Approach.” Psychological Bulletin 115.2: 243–267.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Carlsmith, Kevin M. (2006) “The Roles of Retribution and Utility in Determining Punishment.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 42: 437–451.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carlsmith, Kevin M., Darley, John M., and Robinson, Paul H.. (2002) “Why Do We Punish? Deterrence and Just Deserts as Motives for Punishment.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 83.2: 284–299.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
D'arms, J., and Jacobson, D.. (2000) “The Moralistic Fallacy.” Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 61.1: 65–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dolinko, David. (1991) “Some Thoughts about Retributivism.” Ethics 101: 537–559.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Donatelli, J.L., Bybee, J.A., and Buka, S.L.. (2007) “What Do Mothers Make Adolescents Feel Guilty About? Incidents, Reactions, and Relation to Depression.” Journal of Child and Family Studies 16: 859–875.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Duff, R.A. (2001) Punishment, Communication, and Community. (New York: Oxford University Press).Google Scholar
Eisenberg, N. (2000) “Emotion, Regulation, and Moral Development.” Annual Review of Psychology 51: 665–697.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Feinberg, Joel. (1991) “Punishment.” In Feinberg, Joel and Gross, Hyman, eds., Philosophy of Law, 4th ed. (New York: Wadsworth).Google Scholar
Feinberg, Joel, and Gross, Hyman, eds. (1991) Philosophy of Law, 4th ed. (New York: Wadsworth).Google Scholar
Feinberg, Joel, and Gross, Hyman, eds. (1995) Philosophy of Law, 5th ed. (New York: Wadsworth).Google Scholar
Feinberg, Joel, and Gross, Hyman, eds. (2000) Philosophy of Law, 6th ed. (New York: Wadsworth).Google Scholar
Freud, S. (1989) Civilization and Its Discontents. (New York: Norton).Google Scholar
Frijda, Nico. (1986) The Emotions. (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press).Google Scholar
Garvey, Stephen P. (1998) “Can Shaming Punishments Educate?” University of Chicago Law Review 65.3: 733–794.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hanna, Nathan. (2008) “Say What? A Critique of Expressivist Retributivism.” Law and Philosophy 27: 123–150.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Knowles, D. (1993) “Unjustified Retribution.” Israel Law Review 27: 50–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kochanska, G., Gross, J.N., Lin, M.H., and Nichols, K.E.. (2002) “Guilt in Young Children: Development, Determinants, and Relations with a Broader System of Standards.” Child Development 73.2: 461–482.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Lewis, Helen Block. (1971) Shame and Guilt in Neurosis. (New York: International Universities Press).Google ScholarPubMed
Lindsay-Hartz, J., De Rivera, J., and Mascolo, M.F.. (1995) “Differentiating Guilt and Shame and Their Effects on Motivation.” In Tangney, J.P. and Fischer, K.W., eds., Self-Conscious Emotions, 274–300 (New York: Guilford Press).Google Scholar
Locke, K.D., and Horowitz, L.M.. (1990) “Satisfaction in Interpersonal Interactions as a Function of Similarity in Level of Dysphoria.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 47: 71–84.Google Scholar
Lynd, H. (1956) On Shame and the Search for Identity. (New York: Harcourt).Google Scholar
Mackie, John. (1982) “Morality and the Retributive Emotions.” Criminal Justice Ethics 1: 3–10.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mackie, John. (1991) “Retributivism: A Test Case for Ethical Objectivity.” In Feinberg, Joel and Gross, Hyman, eds., Philosophy of Law, 4th ed., 677–684 (New York: Wadsworth).Google Scholar
Markel, Dan. (2001) “Are Shaming Punishments Beautifully Retributive? Retributivism and the Implications for the Alternative Sanctions Debate.” Vanderbilt Law Review 54.6: 2157–2242.Google Scholar
Moore, M.S. (1982) “Moral Reality.” Wisconsin Law Review, 1982, 1061–1156.Google Scholar
Moore, M.S. (1987) “The Moral Worth of Retribution.” In Schoeman, Ferdinand, ed., Responsibility, Character and the Emotions. (Cambridge, UK, and New York: Cambridge University Press).Google Scholar
Moore, M.S. (1992) “Moral Reality Revisited.” Michigan Law Review 90: 2424–2533.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Moore, M.S. (1993) “Justifying Retributivism.” Israel Law Review 27: 15–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morris, Herbert. (1976) “Guilt and Suffering.” In On Guilt and Innocence: Essays in Legal Philosophy and Moral Psychology. (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press).Google Scholar
Morris, Herbert. (1981) “A Paternalistic Theory of Punishment.” American Philosophical Quarterly 128: 263–271.Google Scholar
Morris, Herbert. (1987) “Nonmoral Guilt.” In Schoeman, Ferdinand, ed., Responsibility, Character and the Emotions: New Essays in Moral Psychology. (Cambridge, UK, and New York: Cambridge University Press).Google Scholar
Murphy, Jeffrie, compiler. (1995) Punishment and Rehabilitation, 3rd ed. (Belmont, CA: Wadsworth).Google Scholar
Murphy, Jeffrie, compiler. (1999) “Moral Epistemology, the Retributive Emotions, and ‘the Clumsy Moral Philosophy’ of Jesus Christ.” In Bandes, Susan, ed., The Passions of Law. (New York: New York University Press).Google Scholar
Murphy, Jeffrie, and Hampton, Jean. (1988) Forgiveness and Mercy. (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nunner-Winkler, G., and Sodian, B.. (1988) “Children's Understanding of Moral Emotions.” Child Development 59: 1323–1338.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Pillsbury, S. (1989) “Emotional Justice: Moralizing the Passions of Criminal Punishment.” Cornell Law Review 74: 655–710.Google Scholar
Roberts, Robert. (2003) Emotions: An Essay in Aid of Moral Psychology. (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rodogno, R. (2008) “Shame and Guilt in Restorative Justice.” Psychology, Public Policy, and Law 14.2: 142–176.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rodogno, R. (2009) “Shame, Guilt, and Punishment.” Law and Philosophy 28: 5.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sayre-McCord, G. (2001) “Mill's ‘Proof’ of the Principle of Utility: A More than Halfhearted Defense.” Social Philosophy and Policy 18: 2.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Skorupski, John. (1999) Ethical Explorations. (Oxford: Oxford University Press).Google Scholar
Solomon, R., and Murphy, M.C., eds. (2000) What Is Justice? Classic and Contemporary Readings, 2nd ed. (New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press).Google Scholar
Stephen, J.F. (1873/1967), Liberty, Equality, Fraternity, edited by White, J. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Tangney, June Price. (1991). “Moral Affect: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 61: 598–607.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Tangney, June Price, and Dearing, Ronda L.. (2002) Shame and Guilt. (New York and London: Guilford Press).Google Scholar
Teroni, F. (2007) “Emotions and Formal Objects.” Dialectica 61.3: 395–415.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Teroni, F., and Bruun, O.. (Forthcoming) “Shame, Guilt, and Morality.” Journal of Moral Philosophy.Google Scholar
Wallbott, H.G., and Scherer, K.R.. (1995) “Cultural Determinants in Experiencing Shame and Guilt.” In Tangney, J.P. and Fischer, K.W., eds., Self-Conscious Emotions, 465–487. (New York: Guilford Press).Google Scholar